Insomniac’s first dive into the superhero genre has been a positive experience. The acclaimed developer of titles like Spyro the Dragon, Ratchet and Clank, Resistance, and Sunset Overdrive made another massive leap by creating one of the best superhero games with Marvel’s Spider-Man. However, how does it stack up against the final game in the acclaimed Batman Arkham series? Widely regarded as the best superhero franchise of all time does Marvel’s Spider-Man outshine the final installment in the Batman: Arkham series or will Insomniac need to step up in the game’s eventual sequel? Let’s find out.

Batman’s Final Adventure Versus Spider-Man’s Debut

Batman: Arkham Knight was one of the most anticipated titles of this generation. After the jaw-dropping end of Batman: Arkham City and Rocksteady confirming that Batman: Arkham Knight was the final game in the series many were hoping for a story that would maintain the series high-standards. The unfortunate the reality is it did not.

Batman: Arkham Knight narrative was crippled due to the identity of the Arkham Knight, which fans already predicted the identity of, which served as a primary plot within the game’s story. Joker and Batman’s mental match serves as a much more entertaining portion of the game, easily overshadowing Scarecrow. Marvel’s Spider-Man doesn’t suffer this issue of flow and predictability.

Marvel’s Spider-Man introduces a steady flow of personal and greater problems for Spider-Man to overcome. Everything serves a purpose and right till the end the narrative throws unexpected curveballs and shocking surprises, leading up to an emotional conclusion. Batman: Arkham Knight’s narrative is good but compared to the emotional rollercoaster in Marvel’s Spider-Man Insomniac left a lot of fans shocked and yearning for more.

Batmobile versus Web Swinging

Both Marvel’s Spider-Man and Batman: Arkham Knight provides ample opportunity to use both Batman and Spider-Man’s numerous talents. Rocksteady provides ample options for both stealth and combat to highlight Batman’s resourcefulness and talents whereas Insomniac has Spider-Man performing acrobatic impossibilities while making snarky remarks and bad jokes.

Insomniac did a fantastic job on the traveling system, making web swinging throughout the city and heading to your objective was half the fun of the entire game. Rocksteady not only gave players the same gliding system from Batman: Arkham City but gave players the chance to use the Batmobile. Unfortunately, whereas traveling NY as Spider-Man never gets old the Batmobile eventually loses its appeal because of its overuse.

Most of the time in Batman: Arkham Knight players have to drag the Batmobile everywhere, sometimes literally. Making most of Batman’s adventure a giant escort mission for the Batmobile. This repetition is driven home by the overuse of armed tanks, one of which serves as a final battle between Deathstroke instead of what could’ve been an incredible 1v1 battle. Driving it everywhere is still a lot of fun but by the end of the game, the appeal of getting into the Batmobile becomes an afterthought, unlike swinging around as Spider-Man.

Winner: Marvel’s Spider-Man

Combat and Stealth

Both games offer their own style of combat. Marvel’s Spider-Man gives a great interpretation of Spider-Man’s Way of the Spider combat style that combines the use of his Spidey Sense, web gadgets, and basic melee attacks wRocksteady’sready’s iconic fighting system is still as rock solid as ever in Batman: Arkham Knight.

The differences are slight but make these two games very different. Insomniac’s system is much more forgiving and offers more breaks in the combo chain and giving the player more breathing room of how to customize their own preference combat style with custom suit modifiers and special attacks.

Batman: Arkham Knight’s is much more rigid, requiring absolute perfection to gain those powerful finishing moves and high combo chains. However, ironically, Batman is much more nimble in combat than Spider-Man, able to dash across the room to hit a target and delay their attack. This rhythmic flow is something Insomniac tries to mimic but cannot, not to the same degree of Batman: Arkham Knight.

Stealth in both games are night and day but Batman: Arkham Knight has more options and opportunities for creative tactics. Marvel’s Spider-Man gives Spider-Man a lot of options such as trip mines but compared to Batman’s wide array of tactics Spider-Man cannot compete.

Winner: Batman: Arkham Knight

Optional Objectives

Both games offered repetitive option objectives but with a common theme. Whether it’s repairing Harry’s research stations or investigating murder scenes with cryptic clues the optional missions in both Marvel’s Spider-Man and Batman: Arkham Knight helped complement the core story and overall world.

Optional objectives in Marvel’s Spider-Man were great to play thanks to the incredible gameplay and Batman: Arkham Knight provided interesting payoffs such as unique boss battles. Marvel’s Spider-Man did the same but not for all, most providing tokens for more suit and gadget unlocks. It’s hard to argue one side over the other here since both games offered their own share of repetitive tasks with great payoffs and kept with the theme of the game and protagonist. In the end, it’s whether you liked playing as Batman or Spider-Man more.

Winner: Tie

Stability

Marvel’s Spider-Man is a stable game. Sounds like a trivial thing to highlight but modern releases tend to have flaws at release that later get patched out. Batman: Arkham Knight launched in such a shameful state that the PC version of the game was recalled within weeks of the game’s launch. The console versions fared better but were not without their flaws with Xbox One users specifically unable to play the game after a certain period unless all internal files were deleted from their system if they purchased a launch day Xbox One.

Marvel’s Spider-Man has its flaws, as do many open world games, but these issues were minimal. Floating NPCs, animation problems, and other issues were tawdry in comparison. Personally, I had 3 hard crashes during my spectacular playthrough but when compared to Batman: Arkham Knight’s release state Marvel’s Spider-Man worked.

Winner: Marvel’s Spider-Man

Closing Statement

Batman: Arkham Knight is a great game, in its current state, but the lukewarm ending to one of the most acclaimed superhero franchises of all time still left a sour taste in many gamer’s mouths. Marvel’s Spider-Man’s debut left a similar mark as the first Batman: Arkham Asylum and hopefully Insomniac will maintain its momentum until the very end.

Winner: Marvel’s Spider-Man

About The Author

Adam S
Sr.Staff Writer

Adam is a Senior Staff Writer for GamerAssaultWeekly with over 5 years of experience in writing and is completely obsessed with video games. He holds a BA from Brooklyn College and lives in NY.

  • andrewsqual

    Probably better off comparing Arkham Asylum since that was the first game in the series just like Marvel’s Spiderman is the first game in that series.

    • bigevilworldwide1 .

      SO then lets compare Arkham Asylum to Spider-man 2 the game….Oh wait thats right people just love to claim that Arkham did so many original things, when its factual that Spider-man has been doing the same type of combat since hell Spider-man the Movie game…Then Spider-man 2 built of that, then Spider-man 3 on 360/PS3 built on that….There is literally NOTHING that Arkham does that was never done before Arkham Asylum…..The only thing you could maybe argue they did first was the fly across the room to hit someone, rather than actually needing to be near an enemy…Everything in Insomniac’s Spider-man game has literally been done in EVERY Spider-man game for years….

      • andrewsqual

        No, I meant if we are comparing Spiderman with the Arkham games, it should be compared to Arkham Asylum since that was the first game in THAT series, just like Marvel’s Spiderman is the first in its series. Maybe in a few years time we can compare the 3rd outing of Insomniac Games’ Spiderman to Rocksteady’s 3rd entry in their Batman Arkham games, Arkham Knight.

        But putting Insomniac Games’s game right up there beside the 3rd outing from Rocksteady Games isn’t really fair or make much sense.

        I wasn’t claiming at all that the Arkham games did anything first. But there is definitely something that has to be said about these 2 studios and how they NAILED both their respective super heroes in videogame form. They brought together amazing tech, animations, voice talent, presentation like barely much loading times. And when you bring all these things together perfectly, you get a critically praised award winning game. ^_^

  • shango thomas

    Graphic wise arkham knight is way beautiful and professional than spiderman

  • JesusChrist

    In terms of gameplay both Games really made you perfectly feel like their respective Heroes.

    • Winterlem

      I agree but I like the gameplay of batman better. Spider man on the other hand I feel has a lot of potential and I’m pretty sure it’s going to improve in the next few iterations

      • John Marston

        Spider-Man’s combat is better. Best animations, gadgets and you need to use analog, unlike Batman haha

        • Winterlem

          I agree, I have to give combat mechanics to Spiderman. They’re both very good in a lot of different ways but Spidey’s gadgets and suits i think is what really tipped the scale. They were super fun!

          Having said that, I still prefer Batman’s gameplay all in all because Batman has better stealth, better puzzle solving, and unlike most people, I actually loved the Batmobile!

          In terms of Gotham vs New York City design. I also have to give it to Batman. New York is lovely but Gotham had so much character. I’m not really sure why, but New york buildings seem a bit too generic save for a few landmark buildings like the empire state. Heck I even think that Infamous’ Seattle was a lot prettier than Spiderman’s New York. But this is just my preference i guess.

  • GrimmyReaper

    Haven’t played either but pretty sure the answer is Batman Arkham City.
    I admit, am a big Batman fan and I do intend to play the Spiderman game as well.
    It looks fun. Bit traditional but hey. So are the Mario games and they are fun too.

    • andrewsqual

      Nobody mentioned Arkham City though lol.

      • GrimmyReaper

        I know. It was a joke 😛
        My fav Spiderman game is probably Ultimate Spiderman on ps2

    • bigevilworldwide1 .

      The answer wouldn’t be Batman anything, since Spider-man games have been doing the EXACT same thing since Spider-man The Movie The Game…..The formula has been improved on in every Spider-man game that followed….With the first 2 movie games existing faaarrr before Arkham Asylum…..There really isn’t anything Rocksteady did that was revolutionary or groundbreaking, except for removing the requirement that you actually be something close to within range of the enemy you want to hit….

      People who keep trying to compare PS4 Spider-man to the Arkham series, haven’t actually played many Spider-man games….

  • TheUltimateTruth

    Knight is probably on par, City and Asylum are both light years ahead, the simple fact is Insomniac is not as talent as Rocksteady and never will be.

    • John Marston

      Nice joke! Spider-Man is so much better. Best fight, best bosses, no tank war (lol) without 300 Riddler trophies. Spider-Man is more fun. Batman is a mix of hacker simulator with tank wars

  • John Marston

    Spider-Man is better at everything. Disappointment with Batmobile: Arkham Knight. It just was not fun.